Keeping the Hints in Three Tiers

Graded hints only work if the tiers are honest about what they give away. That is an information-design problem, not a content problem.

Design notes · 338 words

A hint system is an information leak with a permission slip. The design question is not what to reveal but how to bound the damage of each reveal, and a well-built three-tier structure is a small masterclass in that boundary work.

The structure described on the site is: a direction, a next word, and a route shape. The elegant part is that each tier gives a different kind of information rather than a different amount. A direction is positional: it says where to look. A next word is concrete: it supplies one node. A route shape is structural: it describes the path's pattern without listing it. Because the kinds differ, the tiers do not simply stack, and a player who takes tier two has not necessarily received tier one plus more.

That distinction is what prevents the common failure where tier two makes tier one pointless. If the tiers were "vague hint, clear hint, answer", nobody would ever use the middle. When they are positioned, concrete and structural, each tier has its own moment and its own player.

The second design constraint is that the full route must live somewhere else entirely. Splitting the hint page from the answer page is not tidiness; it makes spoiling a decision rather than an accident. A player can take a direction and stop in the same place, which is much harder when the full route sits underneath the hint text.

The third constraint is wording. A hint that names a position must not name the letter, and a hint that names a word must not name the next. The discipline of writing to that boundary is most of the work, and it is invisible when it is done well.

When a hint fails, the question to ask is which tier would have worked, not which tier is too weak. Try the three hint levels on a genuinely stuck round, then go and visit the site for a fresh daily board and notice whether one level would have been enough.